Preservation + Development = Public Interest
A North Carolina Water Resources Example
N.C.G.S. § 143-211 establishes North Carolina’s responsibility for both the preservation and development of the State’s water and air resources in the best interest of its citizens. Public Logos begins with that rule of law and asks how preservation and development can be measured together in determining the public interest.
How do we measure preservation and development simultaneously?
Measure both against the productive capacity of the same resource over time.
For a groundwater resource, preservation can be measured by the quantity and quality of water maintained within the aquifer and its capacity for recharge. Development can be measured by groundwater withdrawn and put to beneficial use for homes, agriculture, industry, energy, and other productive purposes.
The public-interest question is therefore whether productive use of the resource is sustained within a measurable resource balance over time.
Preservation: Maintain the long-term productive capacity of the aquifer.
Development: Put groundwater to beneficial use that produces public and private value.
Public Interest: Manage preservation and development over an appropriate accounting period so that cumulative development does not consume the productive capacity that preservation is intended to maintain.
For example, if an aquifer receives 100 billion gallons of recharge during one 10-year period while withdrawals total 110 billion gallons, the resource account has accumulated a 10-billion-gallon deficit.
If recharge during the next 10 years is again 100 billion gallons, withdrawals of 90 billion gallons during that period would restore the cumulative 20-year balance:
Preservation: 200 billion gallons of aquifer recharge
Development: 200 billion gallons of groundwater put to beneficial use
Resource Balance: 0 billion gallons cumulative deficit
The accounting principle is simple:
Cumulative Aquifer Recharge ≥ Cumulative Groundwater Withdrawal
The specific measurements, accounting period, geographic boundary, water-quality requirements, and acceptable resource conditions must be established for the resource being evaluated. The purpose of the equation is not to predetermine the answer. It is to make both preservation and development measurable so that the resulting public-interest determination can be evaluated against empirical evidence.